It's time to trade Paolo Banchero

Franz Wagner is pulling the Magic together with his playmaking and aggression, and Banchero's eventual return doesn't solve any of the problems of a Wagner-led team. Orlando can fix their cap sheet and restock their draft equity by moving on.

Share
It's time to trade Paolo Banchero
Two Modelli for Altarpiece in St. Peter's; Simon Vouet; 1625

Franz Wagner is pulling the Magic together with his playmaking and aggression, and Banchero's eventual return doesn't solve any of the problems of a Wagner-led team. Orlando can fix their cap sheet and restock their draft equity by moving on.

Good morning. Let's basketball.


Paolo Banchero is a really good basketball player. He just turned 24 and is one of the better playmaking forwards in the league, a second-tier scorer with some power and toughness. While his team has yet to win a playoff series, he's performed well in the postseason in his opportunities, and taken opponents to seven twice. He's flawed, certainly: he's a minus shooter from deep despite including lots of threes in his shot diet, he could stand to grab more rebounds. But overall, he's a plus player. Maybe not a max player – he'll make around 25% of the salary cap through 2031 – but a talent and a producer.

It's been evident for a couple of years that he really doesn't fit cleanly with Franz Wagner, Orlando's other star forward. Unfortunately for the Magic, since adding Desmond Bane more than a year ago, the duo has been largely unavailable at the same time, so the front office hasn't been able to definitively answer whether their planned core works as a unit. Paolo is slated to miss another 2-3 weeks due to an ankle sprain. Meanwhile, Franz has led Orlando's massive turnaround (they are now 6-8 after having won four of five) and the team looks like it really works with Wagner, Bane, Jalen Suggs, Anthony Black and Wendell Carter Jr. It's not likely to compete for a championship with that core, but it works. It's competitive. It's viable.

It's also, with Banchero in street clothes, massively expensive and on track to get more so. The Magic are over the first apron already and have a $30 million tax bill. Black will be a restricted free agent this summer, and is worth keeping based on recent play and his overall development. The rest of the core is locked in. That's not necessarily a good thing: Wagner, Banchero and Bane all make more than $40 million (25% of the cap) and Suggs is on a descending deal currently at 19% of the cap. While Suggs is among the best defensive guards in the league, he might be the player Orlando would most prefer to move based on his consistent injury issues and lack of outside shooting. (Suggs is a distressed asset other teams in need of perimeter defense should take a look at. His contract is not as bad as the perception. He needs to be paired with a high-volume scoring guard.) Trading Suggs might just be difficult, and at minimum wouldn't net Orlando much helpful to further build the team now or in the future. The same likely applies to Bane, a good player who cost the Magic a ton of assets and is in the general realm of salary status the Apron Era has not been kind to. Carter is a value player and important to Orlando's success unless they can get a better two-way center option, which seems like a difficult ask.